A Luxembourg court yesterday (16 March) gave reduced sentences on appeal to two LuxLeaks whistleblowers convicted of leaking thousands of documents that revealed tax breaks for multinational firms.
Former PricewaterhouseCoopers employee Antoine Deltour, 31, received a six month suspended sentence with a €1,500 fine, instead of the 12-month jail term given at the original trial last June.
His colleague Raphaël Halet, 40, received a €1,000 fine instead of a nine-month prison sentence.
Both were ordered to pay a symbolic sum of €1 each to PricewaterhouseCoopers.
Investigative reporter Edouard Perrin, who used the thousands of pages of documents to produce two reports for French public television in 2012 and 2013, had his acquittal at the earlier trial confirmed.
“The only satisfying judgement would have been acquittal” for all three, Deltour told reporters after the decision.
His lawyer, William Bourdon, said however it was the first case of its kind.
“It’s the first time in Europe that the judge has given a legal justification to a whistleblower on the main charge that he was on trial,” Bourdon said.
“This is a very important stone that we have laid in the building of protection for whistleblowers.”
The LuxLeaks scandal erupted in 2014 and sparked a major global push against generous deals handed to multinationals, which grew even stronger with new revelations such as the Panama Papers and Football Leaks.
The blockbuster leak revealed the huge tax breaks tiny EU nation Luxembourg had offered international firms including Apple, IKEA and Pepsi, at a time when Jean-Claude Juncker, now head of the European Commission, was prime minister.
‘A good thing’
The revelations ended up prompting the EU to take urgent steps to stop global firms avoiding tax in Europe, including anti-trust inquiries into firms like Apple, McDonald’s and Amazon.
The scandal also pressured Luxembourg into accepting a new law that requires EU member states to share tax deal information with its bloc partners.
But Halet told reporters: “The real trial, which has never taken place, should be for tax evasion.”
Several NGOs had demonstrated at the opening of the appeal proceedings and Green MEPs have also called for a change in EU regulations to protect whistleblowers in the workplace.
Luxembourg prosecutors had themselves recommended the reduced sentences following an appeal by the convicted men.
EU Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager appeared to back the whistleblowers in comments earlier this week.
“I think it was a good thing (the leaks),” she told a news conference in Brussels.
“I think it is important when people tell if they find that something is not the way it should be. Then authorities, law enforcers, can do their job and do that in a better way,” she added.
“I think that a lot of people actually have benefitted from them telling what they knew.”
Deltour and Halet had originally faced a maximum penalty of ten years on charges which included stealing documents, revealing business secrets and violation of professional secrets.