Poland to dissolve judges’ Disciplinary Chamber to meet EU demands

Leader of the Polish Law and Justice (PiS) rulling party Jaroslaw Kaczynski attends a press conference at the Polish parliament building in Warsaw, Poland, 7 July 2021. [EPA-EFE/PAWEL SUPERNAK]

Poland will do away with a disciplinary system for judges which the EU’s top court has ruled violates EU law, the head of the ruling PiS party said, in a bid to diffuse a row that could result in financial penalties against the country.

Poland faces a 16 August deadline set by the European Commission to disband the Disciplinary Chamber, which the EU says is being used to pressure judges or to exert political control over judicial decisions, and undercuts the bloc’s laws.

EU Commission gives Poland deadline to comply with CJEU decisions

The EU executive has given Poland a 16 August deadline for it to comply with the order issued by the EU Court of Justice (CJEU) last week, which called on the country to freeze all actions by the disciplinary chamber …

“We will dissolve the Disciplinary Chamber as it currently operates and in this way the subject of the dispute will disappear,” Jarosław Kaczyński, head of the ruling Law and Justice party (PiS) and a deputy prime minister, said in an interview published on Saturday (7 August) with state-run news agency PAP.

Under PiS Poland has clashed with the EU on a number of fronts, such as media independence and the rights of migrants, women and gays.

Some legal experts say the dissolution of the Disciplinary Chamber would be a cosmetic change which would not be enough to satisfy the EU’s top court.

“The mere dissolution of the Disciplinary Chamber doesn’t solve the problem of past, unlawful decisions and sanctions adopted by this body,” said Laurent Pech, professor of European law at Middlesex University, London.

“If they want to comply with EU law, it is quite simple. They have to undo everything they have done for the past five years, there is no other way,” Pech added, referring to a series of measures such as reforms to the Constitutional Tribunal, which will rule on whether the Polish constitution takes precedence over EU treaties this month.

Uncompromising stance

While the Tribunal is nominally independent, most of its judges have been nominated by PiS, some to replace candidates picked by the opposition but whose appointment was refused by President Andrzej Duda, a party ally.

The PiS-led ruling coalition is split over whether to stand firm over its legal reforms or compromise to avoid risking financial sanctions.

Members of junior coalition partner United Poland, led by Justice Minister Zbigniew Ziobro, architect of the reforms, have taken an uncompromising stance.

Poland should not stay in EU at all costs, says minister

Poland should not remain a member of the European Union at all costs, the justice minister said in an interview published on Friday, as he railed against what he called “blackmail” from the bloc over Poland’s judicial reforms.

Asked in an interview published on Friday whether United Poland would remain in the coalition if Poland accepts the EU top court’s ruling, Ziobro said there were “limits to compromise”.

Kaczyński said reform of the judiciary, including a proposal to change the Disciplinary Chamber, had already been planned, but rejected the ruling by the EU’s top court.

“I do not recognise these kinds of rulings as they clearly go beyond the Treaties and extend the jurisdiction of the EU courts,” Kaczynski said, adding the government would put forward its first proposals for reforming the Chamber in September.

PiS spokespeople did not immediately respond to questions about details of the planned reforms.

The head of Poland’s Supreme Court on Thursday partially froze the Disciplinary Chamber, saying no new cases would go to it until legislative changes are introduced or until the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issues a final verdict on the matter.

Subscribe to our newsletters