Swiss seek to avert EU immigration clash with ‘safeguard’ clause

Anti-immigration adverts, Swiss People's Party. [ Richard Allaway/Flickr]

The Swiss government hopes to negotiate for a right to cap immigration from the European Union so as to keep its access to EU markets when it writes into law a popular vote requiring strict limits on migration.

The referendum passed narrowly almost a year ago despite vehement opposition from the government and from the Swiss banks, drugmakers and other industries that rely heavily on skilled workers from the EU.

This handed the government the problem of how to manage immigration through quotas without angering Brussels, which has said any curb on the influx of EU workers would violate treaties that give Switzerland access to EU markets.

Berne diplomats are now exploring adding a “safeguard clause” that would let Switzerland cap immigration from the EU once certain levels were hit, according to two sources familiar with the matter who declined to be named.

Curbs would be imposed when immigration tops a number that is linked to average immigration in the European Union, but also allows for outliers.

Foreigners made up almost 24% of the Swiss population at the end of 2013, one of the highest proportions in any Western economy, up from below 15% 30 years ago. Net immigration is about 1% a year, about twice that of Germany.

The proposal is meant to reassure Swiss voters that a perceived siege by foreign workers will be tackled, while persuading the EU that one of its fundamental principles, free movement of labour, has not been compromised.

Although Switzerland is not in the EU, it has in effect accepted those principles in exchange for market access.

The government’s proposal has gained support from the business establishment, but will be hard to sell to the right-wing Swiss People’s Party (SVP), which launched the referendum.

“We want a bill that adheres to the constitutional change, and it doesn’t seem that adding a safeguard clause would do so. It does not set quotas or give priority to Swiss residents,” Silvia Baer, deputy secretary of the SVP, told Reuters on Wednesday.

The EU said it would not take a view until it received an official proposal. Two diplomats familiar with the matter said it would be very hard for the bloc, currently dealing with its own pressures to limit internal migration, to stomach the safeguard clause.

Other proposals for responding to the referendum have ranged from re-running it in the hope of reversing the narrow “Yes” vote to taking a hard line and risking breaking the treaties.

A narrow majority of Swiss voters backed proposals to reintroduce immigration quotas for the European Union at a referendum held in February last year.

The referendum was held in order to pry open the Swiss labour market to workers from Croatia, which joined the EU on 1 July 2013.

>> Read: EU-Swiss relations in turmoil after immigration vote

Immigration is a hot-button issue in Switzerland where the right-wing Swiss People's Party (SVP) has long blamed rising rents, crowded public transport and higher crime on an influx of foreigners.

The European Commission warned about the "consequences" of the Swiss vote, saying it contravened the principle of free movement of persons between the EU and Switzerland.

In one immediate consequence, the Commission said it was postponing talks on Swiss participation in both the EU's €80-billion Horizon 2020 research programme and its €14.7-billion Erasmus+ educational exchange programme.

>> Read: Switzerland gets first penalty for immigration vote

Switzerland’s immigration policy was until then based on free movement of people from the EU and allowing a restricted number of non-EU citizens to enter the country.

Swiss industry heavyweights such as drugmakers Roche and Novartis as well as banks UBS and Credit Suisse have traditionally looked outside the country for highly skilled and specialised staff.

The Swiss business community has warned that re-imposing immigration quotas on EU citizens quotas would call the country's bilateral agreements with the bloc into question.

Switzerland has since attempted to backtrack on its decision by opening its labour market to Croatian workers. But the move was seen as insufficient by the EU, which asked for a longer-term solution.

>> Read: Switzerland backtracks on immigration curbs

European Commission

Subscribe to our newsletters