Von der Leyen ‘concerned’ over Hungary virus emergency law

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen holds a news conference detailing EU efforts to limit economic impact of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak, in Brussels, Belgium, 02 April 2020. [EPA-EFE/FRANCOIS LENOIR]

European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen expressed “particular” concern on Thursday (2 April) over a coronavirus emergency law in Hungary that has given nationalist premier Viktor Orbán sweeping powers.

While saying EU countries may need extraordinary measures to tackle the pandemic, she added: “I am concerned that certain measures go too far – and I’m particularly concerned with the situation in Hungary.”

Hungary’s parliament, dominated by Orbán’s ruling party, handed the prime minister the power from Tuesday to rule by decree until his government decides the virus crisis is over.

The emergency law also threatens journalists with prison if they publish “falsehoods” about the virus or the government’s actions to slow it.

On Thursday Hungarian government spokesman Zoltán Kovács sharply rejected criticism of the law, saying: “Not only are we being criticised, but we are being subjected to a political witch-hunt and coordinated smear campaign.”

Von der Leyen’s reaction was “a typical example of… political double standards,” Kovács said in a video statement posted to Twitter.

The law has sparked alarm among rights groups, media organisations and several EU countries, with fears it was a power grab by Orbán, who has ruled Hungary for the past decade.

Thirteen EU nations, including heavyweights France and Germany, issued a joint statement on Wednesday that – without explicitly naming Hungary – said they were “deeply concerned about the risk of violations of the principles of rule of law, democracy and fundamental rights arising from the adoption of certain emergency measures”.

13 EU countries say 'deeply concerned' about democracy

Thirteen European governments said they are ‘deeply concerned’ about the risk of violations of rule of law, democracy and fundamental rights, in a stab at Hungary’s recent emergency measures giving the government wide powers, including the right to rule by decree.

Von der Leyen up to now had been similarly circumspect, avoiding singling Hungary out by name. On Tuesday, she emphasised that coronavirus emergency measures in EU countries must be limited, proportionate and cannot last indefinitely.

EU threatens ‘action’

In response to questions on Thursday specifically on Hungary, von der Leyen said where measures do not meet those criteria “we will take action as necessary as we have already done in the past”.

Her Commission, she added, was “mapping the whole situation”.

Orbán’s government argues that it is upholding EU values and press freedom with the emergency law.

On Thursday Hungary’s justice ministry reacted to the joint statement by saying: “We deeply regret that the statement was not open for all Member States to join.”

Values of democracy and human rights “must not be used to create divisions, especially at a time when the European Union is in great need of unity and solidarity,” the ministry said.

Hungary had no objection to scrutiny of its “exceptional measures” but suggested this should take place once the crisis was over.

Orbán seeks EPP backing for his absolute powers

Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán is seeking conservative support to remain within Europe’s main centre-right political bloc despite concerns over his adoption of emergency powers to rule by decree.

Orbán, frequently in hot water with the Commission over his anti-EU stances, is worried about his Fidesz party remaining part of an EU-wide conservative political grouping, the European People’s Party (EPP).

He contacted leading EPP figures including – in a letter obtained by AFP – the head of Germany’s powerful CDU, Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer, appealing for support, party figures said.

EPP head Donald Tusk, former president of the European Council representing EU leaders, has written his own letter to EPP member party chiefs calling Hungary’s emergency measures “disproportionate and inadequate”.

On Thursday leaders of 13 EPP parties called for Fidesz to be expelled and for the European Commission to “address the situation in Hungary forcefully”, with the Greek and Norwegian prime ministers among the signatories.

Centre-right leaders ask Tusk to expel Orban’s Fidesz from EPP

Eleven of Europe’s centre-right political leaders have asked Donald Tusk, the president of the conservative European People’s Party (EPP), to expel Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s Fidesz party from its ranks, according to a letter seen by EURACTIV.com.

Subscribe to our newsletters