The Brief: On Catalonia, time to de-escalate

The Brief is EURACTIV's evening newsletter.

Catalonia caught Europe’s attention like never before this week. The arrest of regional government officials involved in organising the 1 October referendum was published on front-pages across Europe and sparked a torrent of questions from the international press in Brussels.

For the government led by Carles Puigdemont, this step represented “de facto” the suspension of Catalonia’s regional autonomy and the imposition of a “state of emergency”.

Mariano Rajoy’s executive in Madrid had only one option: to enforce the Constitutional Court ruling declaring the referendum illegal.

What else would the judges say of a region that wants to cut ties unilaterally with the rest of the country, when the national constitution, like almost all the fundamental laws in the world – and the EU treaties – enshrine territorial integrity?

In the Commission’s press room the arguments of each side were heard. While some reporters asked about the rights of Catalans being breached, the Commission repeated that the basic principle in this debate is the “fullest respect of the Spanish constitutional order”.

But this response, given in Madrid and echoed in Brussels, leaves the obvious political problem between the two sides unaddressed.

It is almost impossible to summarise in 400 words such a long and tumultuous relationship, in which history, emotions, economy and mistakes made by each side have culminated in an avoidable clash between the country’s political capital and its economic powerhouse.

Coming from the smallest region of Spain, this reporter feels like Frodo jumping into the final battle between mighty forces. But even in the darkest corners of Mordor (or Brussels) reality must shine through.

For the backers, the driving force behind the referendum is “let the Catalans express their will”. But at the last regional elections two years ago, a majority of voters (52%) supported non-independence parties. Still, the electoral law handed the pro-independence bloc a four-seat majority.

Even under these circumstances, a president that rules for all and not only for his power base would have sought a minimum of consensus before starting a legal and political battle with such immense, far-reaching consequences.

But no impartial observer could possibly believe that the referendum bill or its approval in parliament met those minimum standards (a threshold of voters, a thorough democratic debate).

Still, pointing to a few facts will not make the significant group of Catalans that do not feel part of Spain disappear. And you cannot convince someone to fall in love with you using the letter of the law.

So what now? Basically, what politicians are paid for: reaching compromises for the common good. If Barcelona drops its referendum, Madrid is willing to talk about giving more money to the Generalitat, the Catalans’ longstanding demand.

Arguably, Rajoy would have disarmed the process had he shown the same openness years ago.

Now it is Puigdemont’s turn not to make the same mistake. A majority of Catalans want more competences without independence. If he really listens to his fellow citizens, this is the most critical moment for him to prove it.

The Roundup

EU to go zero carbon by 2050, upping its previous 80% emission cut target – will a carbon-free plan be the Juncker Commission’s legacy? Read our exclusive.

Car charging sockets in every building – a once in a decade opportunity to deliver the electric transition, writes Teodora Serafimova.

The Visegrad group takes a harsh stance on refugees: Hungary and Slovakia go to court against quotas, while the ECJ rules against Poland and the Czech Republic. And they sign a letter to Italy’s PM.

The four eastern European countries also signed a declaration against the EU’s proposal to phase out biofuels. One signature leads to another….

Macron seeks to influence the new German coalition government by giving his vision for the EU in the window between vote-counting and cabinet-making.

Germany mistrusts the polls ahead of election day: we take the nation’s pulse 48h before voting starts.

EU socialists push for progressive progress in Tunisia – amid uncertainty over terrorist attacks and a continuously postponed election date.

Integration is a two-way process: Muslims feel European, will the EU reciprocate? Europe’s Network Against Racism thinks it is already too late.

Greece tells China: hands off my white gold! Greeks can’t stand “feta cheese” spelled in ideogram, and eight EU states file a lawsuit against counterfeit delicacies.

Lookout for…

Polls open on Sunday in Germany

Views are the author’s

Subscribe to our newsletters