Trans-Europe Express: Poland’s gagged media continues to worry Europe

Sent out every Friday at noon, Trans-Europe Express gives you an insider's view of the most important coverage from across the EURACTIV media network, its media partners and much more.

Since Poland’s ruling party came to power two years ago, the country dropped 36 places in the media freedom ranking. Journalists of public broadcasters have been losing their jobs and financial pressures are being exerted on commercial companies.

For Reporters Without Borders, there are no doubts that such a spectacular fall in the ranking corresponds to the rule of the current Law and Justice (PiS) government. In a recent report, they concluded that shortly after PiS came to power, the parliament passed a new law allowing for profound changes in the staffing of public broadcasters.

As a result, in the course of two years, more than 230 journalists have lost their jobs, having been fired or forced to leave. Public media use propaganda, praise the government and criticise the opposition.

Reporters Without Borders list outrageous cases of dismissals: longtime sports journalist Tomasz Zimoch was let go only because he gave an interview in which he expressed some distance vis-à-vis the policies of the current authorities.

The organisation also mentions economic stifling of commercial media – state-owned companies and government institutions have drastically reduced their subscription to critical media outlets and have completely stopped posting paid advertisements in them.

Conversely, the outlets supporting the government’s policies have seen their revenues increase by as much as 700% per year (eg. Gazeta Polska).

Reporters Without Borders called on the European Union a year ago to impose sanctions on Poland due to serious violations of media freedom and pluralism.

Lydia Gall from Human Rights Watch is also critical of the Polish authorities for restricting media freedom. She welcomed the call made by the Commission and the European Parliament for a change of the current government policies aimed at limiting media freedom, dismantling the constitutional order, being the checks and balances of power.

“The actions of the Polish government are not only an internal threat, they also undermine the values of the European Union and undermine its credibility as a promoter of human rights in the world,” Gall wrote and called on the EU to activate Article 7 of the Lisbon Treaty against Warsaw.

The Polish government not only intends to stay on its chosen course but is also trying to further tighten the noose around private media in Poland. A planned media law is intended to lead to their “deconcentration” on the market.

The law specifies a threshold of shares in the advertising market that media must not exceed. If this happens, they will be forced to sell them. PiS politicians have repeatedly suggested in public speeches that they would be buying out state-owned companies.

This would most likely lead to a situation in which the bought-out media might only use the narrative in favour of the rulers. If this happens, Poland’s ranking on the Reporters Without Borders list will fall even further, coming closer to that of countries of Central Asia.

Inside Track

Paradise Papers scoop. The International Consortium of Investigative Journalists released the Paradise Papers, a global investigation that reveals the offshore activities of some of the world’s most powerful people and companies, including Queen Elisabeth II.

Waste shortage and nuclear woes. Lithuania plans to build more waste incineration plants, which the government says would cut energy bills but MPs and NGOs fear it would jeopardise recycling targets. Vilnius has also tapped up the Commission for more money to decommission an unsafe Soviet-era nuclear power plant.

Location, location, location. A nuclear power plant on the EU-Belarus border continues to court controversy due to a number of incidents and concerns raised by neighbours, as found during a visit in the ex-Soviet republic.

Jamaican state-of-play. Success in German coalition talks is far from a done deal, even as CDU/CSU leaders Angela Merkel and Horst Seehofer strike a confident tone. EURACTIV Germany has the overview.

France’s German worries. French President Emmanuel Macron sent his Economic Affairs Minister Bruno Le Maire to meet with Berlin’s coalition negotiators, as he fears his eurozone plans might be threatened by the make-up of the new German government.

Berlin-Warsaw ties shaken. Remarks by German defence minister Ursula von der Leyen on the need to support “democratic resistance of the young generation in Poland” were seen as interference in Polish domestic affairs, EURACTIV Poland reports.

Fishy consequences. Denmark’s fishing industry will suffer “severe” economic consequences unless business-as-usual continues after Brexit, a recently published in-depth impact assessment commissioned by the Danish government found.

Romanians take the streets. Thousands of Romanians demonstrated in Bucharest last weekend to “defend the independence of the judiciary” in protest against a government bill that critics say will weaken anti-corruption measures.

Bad timing. Bulgarian PM Borissov blamed the Bulgarian Socialist Party (BSP) for asking for a no-confidence vote at a time when the country is preparing to take up the rotating Presidency of the Council of the EU.

Law on aliens. Austria this week enforced a stricter law on foreigners, which wants to crack down rigorously on people residing illegally in the country, including refugees.

Serbia’s reforms may be losing steam. Foreign investors have urged the EU candidate to stay on the reform path, modernise its administration and bring laws in line with EU legislation.

Lessons from ancient Greece. The son of famed ocean explorer Jean-Jacques Cousteau has an idea for reducing plastic leakage in the environment. It’s low-tech, and thousands of years old. 

Trapped birds. Malta opened its wild bird trapping season in October, disregarding its EU accession promise to outlaw the practice and a pending case at the European Court of Justice.

Views are the author’s

Subscribe to our newsletters