Developing countries fear being duped by green economy


As global rhetoric on the need to move towards green economy gains ground, developing countries fear that the new discourse could be used to justify unilateral trade protection measures, merely strengthening inequalities between rich and poor nations and hindering their development.

A new report on the benefits, challenges and risks of the transition to a 'green economy' was presented last week to national delegations preparing for a major United Nations conference on sustainable development – the so-called 'Rio+20' summit – scheduled to take place in June 2012.

Twenty years after the Rio Earth Summit, the June gathering will seek to secure a renewed political commitment to sustainable development at global level. It is expected to agree on a political document that will guide action on sustainable development policy for decades to come – with greening the economy as its main tool.

But "concerns have been raised by developing countries' delegations that the green economy concept may be misused or taken out of context, and that the promotion of the green economy may give rise of unhelpful or negative developments, and these must be avoided," reads the new expert report.

In his contribution to the report, Martin Khor, executive director of the Geneva-based South Centre – an intergovernmental organisation of developing countries – describes a multitude of risks that may arise from misusing the 'green economy' concept.

Avoid a 'green only' approach

The first risk concerns defining 'green economy' or putting it into practice in a one-dimensional manner that considers it to be purely "environmental," without fully taking into account its development and equality dimensions, writes Khor. This would mean that the 'green economy' concept would supersede the more holistic sustainable development dimension, with a negative effect on developing countries, he notes.

Another danger is a 'one-size-fits-all approach whereby all countries are treated in the same manner, regardless of their stage of development. However, developing countries should be given special treatment and extra flexibility to impose on them more lenient obligations regarding delivering the green economy, Khor stresses.

Risk of using environment for trade protection

Further threats posed by the green economy mentioned in the UN report include using the environment for trade protectionism purposes. "In particular developed countries may use this as a principle or concept to justify unilateral trade measures against the products of developing countries," it notes, citing as an example plans to impose a 'carbon tariff' or 'border adjustment tax' on products from countries which do not impose a CO2 cap on their industry.

In the EU, the idea of carbon border tariffs has been floated as one way to prevent European manufacturing industries from relocating to countries like China, where environmental laws are less exacting. France, in particular, is leading calls to introduce the controversial measure.

Khor notes that the use of trade measures to block imports of developing countries' goods on climate grounds "has the potential to deal a severe blow to the multilateral trading system" and to adversely affect global climate negotiations under the auspices of the UNFCCC.

Countries can already justify the use of unilateral trade measures via GATT Article XX, which establishes a general exception to normal GATT rules. It allows protective measures to be taken on the grounds of protecting human, animal and plant life or health and of conserving exhaustible natural resources, for example.

Additional trade-related risks of misusing the green economy concept include trying to gain market access under the guise of environment – such as developed countries demanding elimination of tariffs on their 'environmental' goods.

Developing countries may also be forced to compete with production that is subsidised in the industrialised world without being able to impose corrective measures themselves, and may also come up against technical standards that their exporters cannot meet, according to the report.

The 2012 UN Conference on Sustainable Development (UNCSD) – or 'Rio+20' summit – is being held exactly two decades after a landmark international conference in Rio de Janeiro.

Hosted by Brazil, the 2012 summit will seek to secure renewed commitment for sustainable development and assess progress done. Its two main focuses are the green economy in the context of sustainable development and poverty eradication, and the institutional framework for sustainable development.

Subscribe to our newsletters