EU to table oil, mining transparency bill


This article is part of our special report Raw Materials.

To combat illegal exploitation of conflict minerals in Africa, the European Commission is expected to table by November a proposal for an EU law asking large companies to reveal their oil and mining activities to shareholders.

The EU executive will table a proposal to include "mandatory country-by country disclosure" of money flows between mining companies and governments, a senior Commission official told the Financial Times.

The EU law will use the so-called 'Dodd-Frank' bill in the US as a minimum standard, said Klaus Rudischhauser.

The EU proposal is expected to be agreed eighteen months after the Dodd-Frank Act, a bill on so-called "conflict minerals", was adopted in the US (July 2010).

The US law requires oil, gas and mining companies listed on Wall Street to publicly disclose their income and tax payments. It also requires companies to certify whether their products contain minerals from rebel-controlled mines in Congo and other countries with oil and mining activities.

Minerals such as cobalt from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) attracted international attention after being labelled 'conflict' or 'blood minerals' as the mining of these resources is reported to finance armed groups, which are waging bloody wars and committing atrocities to intimidate local populations in order to secure control of mines.

EU's 'Dodd-Frank Plus'

Rudischhauser told the FT that the EU executive is currently mulling whether to "include other companies not in the extractive industries, such as forestry or consumer goods," in the EU bill and whether there should be "disclosure of profits in addition to disclosure of taxes".  

With plans for fuller disclosure, the initiative is already being dubbed 'Dodd-Frank Plus'.

The issue of transparency in the extractive industries is being addressed within a wider context of reforming EU financial markets. Late last year, a public consultation was organised to gather European stakeholders' views on financial reporting by multinational companies.

Rudischhauser's comments came on the fringes of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) global conference, which gathered leaders from governments, companies and civil society organisations in Paris this week.

The EITI aims to strengthen governance by improving transparency and accountability in the extractive sector and supports improved governance in resource-rich countries through the verification and full publication of company payments and government revenues from oil, gas and mining.

The EU already supports the initiative and the Commission's February communication on raw materials suggests further enhancing European financial and political support for the EITI, and helping developing countries to implement it.

An EU 'Dodd-Frank' bill would be more binding than the EITI.

European oil companies like Royal Dutch Shell are reportedly lukewarm about the idea of an EU 'Dodd-Frank' bill, arguing that it threatens to destroy the existing Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI).

But a report released this week by Transparency International (TI) and Revenue Watch Institute (RWI) on revenue transparency in the extractive industries sheds doubt on the existing movement's success. While it said oil and gas companies have improved the transparency of how they report revenues and information about anti-corruption programmes, the report revealed that none of the eight EU oil and gas companies reviewed had divulged details of payments made to governments in Algeria, Egypt and Libya.

"It is good news that transparency is improving, but too few companies publish what they pay governments in each country where they operate. Two thirds of the world's poor live in resource-rich countries. They have a right to know how much money their governments get from companies to exploit these resources," said Huguette Labelle, chair of TI.

Frank Hoffmeister, deputy head of cabinet for EU Trade Commissioner Karel de Gucht, said the Commission had looked at creating a Kimberley Process-esque certification scheme for minerals, but that "similar schemes would not work for minerals for a number of reasons – not least because of the very complex supply chain and issues of traceability".

The Kimberley Process Certification Scheme (KPCS) is a process to certify the origin of rough diamonds from sources which are free of conflict funded by diamond production. In place since 2003, it aims to prevent warlords from earning money by trading blood diamonds.

  • 2-3 March 2011: 5th Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) global conference in Paris.
  • Nov. 2011: Commission expected to table 'Dodd-Frank Plus' bill.

Subscribe to our newsletters