Granting China MES will be ‘catastrophic’, aluminium industry warns

China was promised the status change by the end of 2016. [EBS]

If the European Commission grants China Market Economy Status (MES) the consequences for the EU aluminium sector will be enormous, an industry group has said.

The EU executive said last month that it would focus on new measures to tackle Chinese dumping and illegal subsidies, but won’t decide whether China’s economy is market-driven.

MES is controversial because, if granted, trade partners will have to treat Communist-ruled China as a free market equal when it comes to settling disputes.

EU dodges China 'market economy status' question

The EU said on Wednesday (20 July) it will no longer debate whether or not China’s economy is market driven, but will instead focus on new measures to tackle Chinese dumping and illegal subsidies.

Gerd Götz, director general of trade association European Aluminium, recently said that the EU steel crisis has skewed the debate on China’s MES and distracted Brussels from other European industries, such as the aluminium sector, which could face the same fate.

“If the EU grants China MES, it would put 80,000 European aluminium workers at risk of losing their jobs,” he warned, adding that opening the door to China– regardless of mitigating measures – would jeopardise the EU’s long-term industrial future”.

China says that when it joined the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in 2001, it was promised the status change by the end of 2016. But the 28-country European Union oppose the move as letting Beijing off the hook over a long series of disputes ranging from steel to solar panels.

The Commission announced last week (4 August) that it would retroactively introduce anti-dumping duties on imports of cold-rolled steel products from China and Russia.

China, Russia steel hit with EU anti-dumping duties

Brussels  announced on Thursday (4 August) that it would levy retroactive anti-dumping duties on imports of cold rolled steel products from China and Russia.

“In the wake of the global steel overcapacity crisis, the Commission is applying the trade defense instruments to re-establish a level playing field between EU and foreign producers,” the Commission said in a statement.

The aluminium case

The European aluminium industry argues that China’s overcapacity in primary aluminium is five times the size of the EU’s entire production. China is ramping up production across the value chain, including in semi-fabrication, where exports to the EU increased by 21% in 2015 and by 17% in 2014.

The Chinese share of global primary aluminium production grew from around 10% to over 50% in just over a decade.

The Chinese government systematically subsidises strategic sectors like steel but also aluminium, solar panels, and bicycles, Götz added.

“State-supported aluminium smelters enable Chinese producers to sell at artificially low prices, to the detriment of EU companies that compete fairly and follow EU rules. The EU must therefore refrain from granting MES until it truly becomes a market economy.”


Evangelos Mytilineos, chairman and managing director of Mytilineos Holdings S.A., agreed with Götz. Mytilineos said that like steel, aluminium is being globally destroyed by Chinese practices.

“There is absolutely no doubt whatsoever that the Chinese aluminium market is insane […] it has no connection to the real world it has no connection to the real cost of producing material, no connection to the sales prices, no connection to the markets,” he noted.

Mytilineos said that aluminium consistently had high growth in recent years and it is expected to stay in high demand for the next ten years.

The European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) recently warned against granting China market economy status (MES) and called on the EU institutions to defend European jobs and values with “efficient trade defence instruments (TDIs)”.

“Europe's industry needs a level playing field and it is the EU's responsibility to ensure it by providing the necessary trade defence instruments," said Andrés Barceló, rapporteur of the EESC opinion “Market economy status for China”.

“Granting unconditional market economy status to China would seriously jeopardise Europe’s industry, kill off jobs and damage SME’s local production,” he added.

Subscribe to our newsletters