VW’s bestselling Audi under microscope after EU emissions tests

NOX emissions from the latest Euro 6 diesel generation A3 was double the EU limit. [Kārlis Dambrāns / Flickr]

Audi’s top-selling model released excessive toxic diesel emissions in results from lab tests run by the European Commission, raising suspicions of wrongdoing at Volkswagen’s luxury division.

The results threaten to embroil Audi, the main contributor to VW group profit, in the scandal that has engulfed the company since it admitted cheating U.S. emissions tests with software to mask nitrogen oxides (NOx).

The lab tests run by the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre (JRC) in August showed the latest Euro 6 diesel generation A3 emitted 163 milligrammes (mg) of nitrogen oxides (NOx) per kilometre, double the statutory 80mg cap.

A separate lab-based test showed the A3 emitting 140mg of NOx at an engine temperature of 10 degrees Celsius, but emissions were below 80mg when the car was run with a cold engine.

“The differences between cold start and hot start are hard to explain,” said Bas Eikhout, a lawmaker on the European Parliament’s inquiry committee into the VW scandal.

Audi dismissed the results, saying the level of 163 milligrammes was inflated by erroneous measurements on behalf of the JRC. Key parameters such as the state of the catalytic converter systems of the tested vehicles remain unclear, a spokesman said by email.

EU stalls pledge to carry out independent checks on car emissions

Plans for independent checks of how much pollution new cars emit are being killed off by EU member states, according to leaked documents seen by EURACTIV’s partner The Guardian.

Other tests in Britain and Germany have shown the A3 compact, which topped the brand’s sales rankings this year ahead of the A4 and A6 models, is complying with legal limits, he said.

EU regulators depend on the JRC’s work to help to shape policy, but member states are responsible for policing their car industries.

A Commission spokeswoman said that the JRC’s results were still preliminary.

“If the test results raise some suspicion of wrongdoing, such as the installation of prohibited defeat devices, they will be shared with all relevant approval authorities,” she said.

Germany’s KBA motor vehicle authority declined to comment.

Amid frustration in Brussels about inaction from governments over the Dieselgate scandal, the EU began legal action this month against seven countries, including Germany, for not fining VW over its use of illegal software.

VW has set aside €18.2 billion to cover the costs of the biggest corporate scandal in its history.

In Europe, however, VW has not admitted to using illegal software. Carmarkers in the bloc say that an exemption in EU law allows them to turn off emissions-control systems if that is needed to protect engines.

VW says 'defeat device' in conformity with European law

Volkswagen said the software allowing its diesel vehicles to evade emissions rules does not violate European law, as the carmaker aims to toughen its legal defenses in view of a possible rise in compensation claims in its home region.

Signs of further emissions irregularities come at a bad time for VW as it tries to negotiate a deal with US authorities on possible buybacks and fixes for about 80,000 polluting Audi, Porsche and VW 3-litre vehicles.

Audi also came under scrutiny last month over whether some gasoline vehicles have separate software that lowered carbon dioxide emissions.

Many car brands emit more pollution than Volkswagen, report finds

A year on from the “Dieselgate” scandal that engulfed Volkswagen, damning new research reveals that all major diesel car brands, including Fiat, Vauxhall and Suzuki, are selling models that emit far higher levels of pollution than the shamed German carmaker.

Subscribe to our newsletters

Subscribe