Britain violates EU pollution law, court rules


British judges ruled yesterday (1 May) that the British government has breached EU air quality rules and asked the European Court of Justice for guidance on what action needs to be taken, delaying immediate improvements to air pollution.

Britain's highest appellate court, the Supreme Court, said the government was in breach of an EU directive which put limits on nitrogen dioxide (NO2), a colourless, odourless gas produced by burning fuels which can damage people's breathing.

London has the highest levels of NO2 of any European capital. Around 29,000 early deaths a year in Britain are attributed to air pollution, according to a body which advises the British government.

Before deciding on further action, the Supreme Court referred a number of legal questions to the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg, which could take up to 18 months to answer.

The Supreme Court could eventually force the UK government to take certain steps to improve air quality but does not have the power to issue fines, said Alan Andrews, a lawyer at ClientEarth which brought the case against the government in 2011.

The environmental law firm wanted to force the government to come up with an air quality plan to comply with EU limits on N02 concentrations by 2015.

The High Court and the Court of Appeal refused to take action on the issue and the case went to the Supreme Court.

"This historic ruling marks a turning point in the fight for clean air and will pile the pressure on Owen Paterson," said James Thornton, chief executive of ClientEarth, referring to the UK Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.

"He must now come up with an ambitious plan to protect people from carcinogenic diesel fumes," he added, which are largely blamed for creating NO2.

Jenny Bates of Friends of the Earth said in a statement: "This is a significant judgment that ministers must not ignore. The UK’s attitude to air pollution is a national scandal – thousands of people die prematurely every year because of poor air quality. We urge ministers to take urgent action to tackle this crisis, including scrapping plans to build more roads.”

Under the EU Air Quality Directive, EU member states were supposed to comply with limits on NO2 in 2010 but the deadline could be extended by five years if a plan to deal with high levels of NO2 was delivered.

Court documents show 40 out of Britain's 43 air quality zones exceeded the limits for 2010 and the government's Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) has said 23 zones might comply by 2015 and 16 between 2015 and 2020, while London is not expected to comply before 2025.

Subscribe to our newsletters