The EU’s Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier on Wednesday (19 February) expressed irritation at a combative tweet from British Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s office claiming that Brussels is shifting objectives in upcoming trade talks.
“I have no time to lose in polemics right now. I recommend, on both sides, that we remain calm and face the reality, the truth and the economic, social and human consequences of Brexit,” Barnier told AFP.
Staircase to no deal
The offending tweet republished a two-year-old slide used by Barnier displaying the trade options available to the UK according to various negotiating red lines, pictured as a staircase.
Above it, Johnson’s press office wrote: “In 2017 the EU showed on their own slide that a Canada-style FTA (free trade agreement) was the only available relationship for the UK. Now they say it’s not on offer after all. Michel Barnier what’s changed?”
In 2017 the EU showed on their own slide that a Canada type FTA was the only available relationship for the UK. Now they say it’s not on offer after all. @MichelBarnier what’s changed? pic.twitter.com/ve8zeAqbSZ
— No.10 Press Office (@Number10press) February 18, 2020
One European official, speaking to AFP on condition of anonymity, described the post from the Number 10 press office as “deeply false, dishonest”.
The tweet referred to the biggest point of contention in the negotiations: the EU’s insistence that Britain must hew to the bloc’s labour, environmental and tax standards — to ensure a “level playing field” — if it wants a free trade pact.
Although that demand has been made in EU documents and in a non-binding political declaration Britain signed last year, the UK is baulking at having to abide by EU rules now that it is no longer part of the bloc.
“It’s wrong to say we’ve changed our position. It has always been very clear that a free trade deal is linked to a level playing field,” the EU official said, adding that the UK tweet was received “very negatively” in Brussels.
Another official, also speaking on condition of anonymity, said the tweet was “more meant for the internal debate in the United Kingdom,” where several business sectors want to keep close trading ties with the EU.
That official noted that each FTA is different, and Britain’s situation is unique because it was within Europe with an economy that was deeply intertwined with its EU neighbours.
A Canada-style FTA *is* on offer, but with extra guarantees for a level playing field because of the UK's geographic proximity.
The EU27 have made this very clear for three years, first in Council Conclusions adopted shortly after Theresa May triggered article 50 in 2017. pic.twitter.com/dXX2UL1Wmp
— Dave Keating (@DaveKeating) February 18, 2020
“Imports from Canada, Japan and South Korea together are less than UK imports,” the official said.
It's SLIDE WARS! Michel Barnier's team has created this new slide in response to David Frost's speech on Monday and the argument in the No 10 tweet below. It shows the value of trade to distance ratio of the EU's trade with the UK compared to countries it currently has FTAs with. https://t.co/WrIGQhGAoS pic.twitter.com/0eCZtAprEJ
— Nick Gutteridge (@nick_gutteridge) February 19, 2020
Britain left the EU at the end of last month but enjoys a transition period through the end of this year, during which it is allowed to trade like an EU member. That period is meant to provide space to negotiate a deal on a future relationship. But the tone between Brussels and London has been deteriorating, with Britain increasingly saying it is ready to eschew a trade deal rather than cede “sovereignty” to the EU.
The British government’s own figures show that the UK economy will suffer from Brexit even if a trade deal would mitigate that to a degree. Without one, potential growth would be crimped further.
Some of the back-and-forth happening now is seen as chest-beating before the negotiations begin next month.