EU lawmakers urge UK to adopt alternative Brexit plan

Guy Verhofstadt, leader of the ALDE Liberal group at the European Parliament, handshakes Michel Barnier the European Chief Negotiator of the Task Force for the Preparation and Conduct of the Negotiations with the United Kingdom under Article 50 of the EU at the European Parliament in Strasbourg, France, 17 May 2017. [EPA/Patrick Seeger]

With no majority in the UK parliament for a third vote on the withdrawal agreement, EU lawmakers have called on British MPs to back an alternative Brexit plan or leave without a deal. 

“The game is over,” said Spanish lawmaker Esteban González Pons during a press briefing at the European Parliament in Strasbourg.

“They have to decide – it is in or out,” the vice president of the European People’s Party (EPP), the largest political group in the EU assembly, added.

“We still don’t know what the British politicians want. We know what they don’t want. They are able to vote against everything. We don’t know yet what would they vote yes for,” González Pons said. 

The Spanish MEP called on British MPs to decide this week. If they want to remain in the EU, he said, the UK will have to hold elections. If they don’t, “it is time to leave, whatever the consequences.” 

“It is not for us to decide,” added Philippe Lamberts, a Green MEP from Belgium, as he walked out of a Brexit steering committee meeting in Strasbourg on Tuesday (26 March) evening. 

“You know the calendar. On 12 April they have to come with a plan and if they don’t, then it is a no-deal Brexit,” Lamberts said.

However, any new Brexit strategy in the UK has to come with a majority that can back it, he warned. 

Back May's Brexit deal and you get more time, EU leaders tell Westminster

EU leaders will grant the United Kingdom a possible eight-week delay to Brexit provided that the House of Commons passes the Withdrawal Agreement next week, according to conclusions agreed the European Council summit on late Thursday (21 March) night.

‘Brexit revolt’

For Guy Verhofstadt, the president of the Parliament’s Brexit steering committee, the vote in the House of Commons to take control of the Brexit negotiation was good news. 

There is a “Brexit revolt” happening, the liberal group leader said in reference to the march for a second referendum which mobilised one million people on Saturday, and the online petition to revoke Article 50 which has now registered over 5 million signatures. 

Monday’s vote in the House of Commons “means it is possible to work on a cross-party alliance” in the British parliament – not to change the withdrawal agreement “but to upgrade significantly the political declaration” attached to it, Verhofstadt said.

“But if the parliament decides that they want Norway or Norway +,” they will have to back the withdrawal agreement, Philippe Lamberts warned. “That is the foundation of it.”

Asked how long such a process would take, Lamberts said it could be done overnight.

“May must not waste any more time. Instead she should work with Labour for a closer EU-UK relationship, or put the question back to the British people,” Socialist and Democrats leader Udo Bullman told EURACTIV in a recent interview. 

The ball is in London’s court

Whether British MPs can agree on an alternative proposal remains to be seen, however.  And even if the House of Commons comes up with a plan, it would have to be backed by the British government. 

“We are not talking to Westminster, we are talking to 10 Downing Street,” Philippe Lamberts reminded. “If 10 Downing Street does not reflect the majority of the parliament, what can we do? We cannot force the hand of the British government,” he said. 

Gabriele Zimmer, a leftist MEP who also sits on the Parliament’s Brexit committee, believes it is impossible for Theresa May to get a majority for the withdrawal agreement by the end of the week, as requested by EU leaders.

“We are waiting for a decision of a majority of the British MPs so that we know what they want and can react to that decision,” Zimmer said.

“Frankly, it is not us who have been holding up the process,” Zimmer pointed out. “Don’t expect the solution to come from this side of the channel. It will come from Westminster or it will not come at all,” Lamberts agreed. 

The Brexit steering committee met on Tuesday (26 March) to discuss with European Commission chief negotiator Michel Barnier the state of play of the negotiation. A source close to the committee told EURACTIV Barnier admitted his impression was member states believed more than ever in a potential no-deal.

After the meeting, Verhosftadt met Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker with whom, among other things, he discussed Brexit preparedness.

The clock is ticking

EU heads of state decided on Thursday (21 March) to grant an extension for the Brexit negotiation in two stages. 

If the House of Commons backs the withdrawal agreement in a third vote this week, the UK would have until 22 May to adopt the legislation required to implement the deal. 

Failing that, the government would have until 12 April to decide on an alternative plan. If their decision is to further extend article 50 negotiations, the UK would have to hold European elections in May. 

A majority of parliamentarians voted a proposal to take back control of the Brexit talks on Monday after Theresa May admitted she does not have a majority behind her deal and refused to put it to a vote. 

On Wednesday (27 March), the House of Commons will start holding indicative votes on alternative Brexit plans in a bid to find a plan that could get a majority in the House. 

[Edited by Frédéric Simon and Sam Morgan]

UK Parliament takes back control of Brexit from May

UK Members of Parliament began the process of taking control of the Brexit process from Theresa May’s government on Monday (25 March), paving the way for a series of votes on alternatives to May’s twice rejected Brexit deal.

Subscribe to our newsletters