EU leaders give thumbs up to Juncker, Britain isolated

Jean-Claude Juncker. Cyprus, May 2014. [Jean-Claude Juncker/Flickr]

After weeks of discussion and a bruising confrontation with Britain, EU leaders finally gave the thumbs up to Jean-Claude Juncker to lead the European Commission for the next five years.

The decision, which now has to be approved by the European Parliament at its mid-July plenary session, took centre stage on the EU’s political scene since the European elections took place on 25 May, amid fierce resistance by UK Prime Minister David Cameron.

Italy’s centre-left prime minister, Matteo Renzi, who was initially lukewarm, finally backed Juncker in exchange for greater flexibility in the interpretation of EU budget rules and a shift in focus from austerity to pro-growth economic policies.

>> Read: EU leaders tie slower deficit reduction to reforms

The real winner, sources concur, is the European Parliament which, with a creative reading of the Lisbon Treaty, has initiated a procedure of nominating lead candidates for European Commission presidency, giving a face of the EU election campaign.

In the end, EU leaders approved a candidate that centre-right leaders had elected three month ago to lead the EU election campaign of the European People’s Party’s (EPP) at a congress in Dublin.

>> Read: Juncker beats rival in centre-right race for EU presidency

Speaking as acting president of the European Parliament, Italian centre-left MEP Gianni Pittella told EU leaders that the May elections have been a turning point for the EU as for the first time all major European parties presented lead candidates – or Spitzencandidaten – for the post of Commission president.

“The process of lead candidates has deepened a European-wide debate about European issues,” he said. “And without doubt, via this process the EU has become closer to its citizens, more transparent and more democratic.”

Cameron, the EU’s isolated ‘enfant terrible’

Juncker’s appointment comes as a blow for David Cameron, who led a campaign to block Juncker, but found himself increasingly isolated, as more countries rallied behind Juncker, except for Hungary.

Despite his defeat, the British Prime Minister said he ‘lost one battle but not the war’. He called the nomination of Juncker “a serious mistake”. “This is going to be a long, tough fight,” he said, adding that the ‘Spitzenkandidaten’ process was unacceptable, as it did not allow any serving prime minister to stand in the race. “This process developed a momentum of its own,” he insisted, saying that it sidelined smart and capable leaders.

“This is a bad day for Europe. It hands new power to the European Parliament,”Cameron said. “This whole process has simply reinforced my conviction that the EU has to change.” 

David Lidington, Britain’s Europe minister, had warned earlier this week that choosing Juncker for the Commission job risked turning the EU executive into “a creature” of the European Parliament, a view that was apparently not shared by a majority of EU member countries.

EU leaders have nonetheless offered political concessions to Britian. They added in their final statement that London’s concerns about the future direction of the EU ‘will need to be addressed’ and that the principle of an ‘ever closer union’ in the treaties allowed for different paths of integration for different countries.

They also agreed to review the process for appointing the president of the European Commission once the new executive was in place.

>> Read: Opposition to Juncker wanes, Cameron isolated

The campaign turned ugly and personal in the run-up to the EU summit.

Juncker, the former long-serving prime minister of Luxembourg and son of a steelworker, was caricatured in the British press as a dangerous European arch-federalist, bent on alcohol and chain-smoking. British tabloid papers threw dirt on his father, saying he served in the Wehrmacht.

As the summit meeting resumed this morning in Brussels, Cameron told reporters: “There are times when it is important that you stick to your principles and you stick to your convictions. It is not right for the elected heads of government of the European countries to give up their right to nominate the head of the European Commission. And it is the wrong person,” he said, underlining his objections.

>> Read: Cameron vows to fight Juncker ‘to the end’

David Cameron has promised Britons an in/out referendum on the UK’s EU membership if he is re-elected next year, and said he would push the vote forward if Juncker was appointed.

Finland’s new prime minister, Alexander Stubb, said “we need to build some bridges” between the programme the UK puts forward, and the position of other member states on Juncker at the top of the executive. “But in the UK, I think people should really wake up and smell the coffee.”

Leaders will meet on 16 July, after the Parliament vote on Juncker, to discuss the appointments for the other top jobs, including the High Representative for Foreign affairs and security policy and the European Council president, as well as the composition of the next Commission.

Co-presidents of the Greens/EFA group in the EU Parliament, Rebecca Harms and Philippe Lamberts, stated: "It is certainly welcome to have a pro-European candidate, who is committed to European integration and is not insensitive to the growing social injustice in Europe. [...]Domestic political wrangling and national interests cannot be the basis for selecting the remaining top EU posts and the Commission college. [...] The key position of EU foreign policy representative must be filled by a man or a woman who brings great diplomatic experience. There is also a clear need to ensure gender balance at the top of the EU institutions."

Manfred Weber MEP, Chairman of the EPP Group in the European Parliament, issued the following statement: “The voice of the European citizens has been heard. In putting forward the candidate who has been the face of the European People’s Party throughout the European elections campaign, the EU Heads of State and Government have taken an important step towards more democracy and transparency in Europe.”

“Jean-Claude Juncker’s nomination is a success for the EPP. European voters have put their trust in us. They have made us yet again the largest political group in the European Parliament. What they now expect from us is to deliver. This is our responsibility. We need a strong European Commission that will put forward a reform agenda to promote growth and jobs in Europe.

Guy Verhofstadt, group leader of the liberals and democrats in the European Parliament, said: "For the first time, European voters can see there is a direct link between how they voted and the leadership of the EU. This is an important step in our political development and an historic precedent. It means in the first place a strengthening of European democracy with still a long way to go to bridge the gap between the EU and its citizens."

Acting President of the European Parliament Gianni Pittella, said: "This unprecedented election process is an historic a turning point for the European Union. The ball is now firmly in the court of the European Parliament, and we will exercise our power swiftly, transparently and democratically. Jean-Claude Juncker now has the mandate to form a majority in the European Parliament. We as representatives of the people must now swiftly agree on a political programme for the next legislature. This will help Europe to finally get out of the crisis and make people's lives better."

Katja Hall, deputy-director general of the UK's business lobby CBI, said: “The recent election results were an unmistakable call for change and a better working Europe, so the new Commission leadership will need to be as good as their word on reforming the EU with jobs and growth top of the agenda. We all want a Europe that can compete with the rest of the world and so the time for a political tug-of-war has passed and the push for a more competitive EU must begin. When the new Commission gets to work it must have a greater focus on signing trade deals, completing the Single Market and making sure Europe only intervenes with regulation where it can genuinely add value.”

UK Prime Minister David Cameron has waged a campaign to block the former Luxembourg Prime Minister and EU veteran Jean-Claude Juncker from becoming the next President of the European Commission.

Juncker is seen as the legitimate candidate for the post because he campaigned during the European elections as the leading figure of the centre-right European People's Party (EPP), which won the largest number of seats in Parliament.

But Cameron refuses this logic, saying Juncker's candidacy did not appear on the ballot papers at the May election.

He insisted that EU heads of states and government take a vote on the matter during an EU summit on 27 June, knowing he does not have a blocking minority.

Cameron has promised Britons an in/out referendum on Britain's EU membership if he is re-elected in 2015 and said he would push the vote forward if Juncker was appointed.

  • 1-3 July: First plenary session of the newly constituted European Parliament. Informal negotiations with EU heads of states
  • 14-17 July: Parliament votes to approve or reject Commission president nominee in Strasbourg plenary session;
  • 16-July: EU leaders will meet for an emergency summit to decide how to fill key posts,
  • Summer: National leaders designate their commissioners to Brussels. New president distributes portfolios within his team of 28 commissioners
  • September: Each commissioner is scrutinised in individual hearings before Parliament committees
  • October: European Parliament votes to approve or reject new Commission College as a whole
  • 1 November: Target date for new Commission to take office

Subscribe to our newsletters