Spain eases opposition to an independent Scotland in EU

Nicola Sturgeon

Leader of the Scottish National Party (SNP), Nicola Sturgeon reacts at the Emirates Arena in Glasgow, Scotland, Britain, 06 May 2016 (reissued 28 March 2017). [Robert Perry/ EPA]

Spain, at loggerheads with Britain over Gibraltar, appears to be easing its opposition to an independent Scotland in the European Union, saying it would not block such a move at least initially.

The Scottish independence drive, now resuscitated by the prospect of Britain’s departure from the EU, is highly controversial in Spain because of the secessionist movement in Catalonia.

As a result, Madrid has long been seen as an obstacle to an independent Scotland joining the EU after Brexit. But its foreign minister, Alfonso Dastis, threw that in doubt yesterday (2 April).

“Initially, I don’t think we would block it,” he said in an interview published in El País.

But he added Scotland would have to leave the EU with Britain, and “the rest we will see”. He also said Spain did not welcome fragmentation of Europe.

“Having said that, if, in application of its laws, the outcome of that process is a division of the United Kingdom, any part of the United Kingdom that becomes a state and wants to join the EU will have to apply. And follow the steps that are stipulated,” he said.

Scottish minister: We are better off without London

After declaring independence from the UK, Scotland will improve its relationship with England. However, we have to make decisions about key affairs ourselves. Today, Europe is the most important, Alasdair Allan told EURACTIV’s partner Gazeta Wyborcza.

Gibraltar tussle

The comments come after a week in which the issue of Gibraltar, a British oversees territory on Spain’s south coast, has stirred tensions between London and Madrid.

The EU has said that, following Brexit itself, no future EU-Britain pact that affects Gibraltar can be made without Madrid’s approval.

Britain has reacted sharply, saying its support for the territory, ceded by Spain in 1713 and which wants to remain British, is “implacable”.

Dastis refused talk about veto rights when it comes to Gibraltar but said he viewed the EU’s stance very positively.

“When the United Kingdom leaves the EU, the EU partner is Spain, and in the case of Gibraltar the EU is therefore obliged to take the side of Spain,” he said. “I do not think it’s necessary to talk about vetoes”.

EU-27 hands Spain veto over Gibraltar’s Brexit deal

Spain is likely to wield a veto over any Brexit deal for Gibraltar after the EU-27 backed Madrid in its draft negotiating guidelines for forthcoming divorce talks between the UK and the bloc.


Dastis said that Spain’s stance to not bloc attempts by Scotland to join the EU had nothing to do with Catalonia, where a vehemently pro-independence local administration took power in 2015 and with whom tensions are high.

“In Scotland there was a referendum in accordance with the laws,” he said, referring to the 2014 vote to remain in Britain. “In Spain it cannot be in accordance with the Constitution. They (Scotland and Catalonia) are not comparable cases.”

Catalonia has vowed to hold an official referendum on its potential split from Spain later this year.

Germany backs Spain's Catalonia position, Scottish comparison avoided

The German government yesterday (28 March) endorsed Spain’s position on Catalonian sovereignty and avoided making any comparisons with Scotland’s own push for independence. EURACTIV Spain reports.

Regarding Brexit in general, Dastis said Spain preferred a “soft Brexit” – one in which Britain remained linked through such things as tech single market – though he doubted this would be possible.

However, he said Spain wanted to have a close relationship with Britain.

“As close as possible to what we have now. If that is to be defined as Brexit soft I am not uncomfortable with that,” he said.

Scotland’s independence debate is now intrinsically tied with Brexit

Scotland’s nationalists hope the country’s pro-EU stance will translate into votes for independence. To ensure a European future for an independent Scotland, the next referendum must take place before the UK and the EU drift too far apart, writes Anthony Salamone.

Subscribe to our newsletters