The Brief, powered by FACEBOOK – The horse and his cart of euros

DISCLAIMER: All opinions in this column reflect the views of the author(s), not of EURACTIV Media network.

The Brief is EURACTIV's evening newsletter. [Shutterstock/esfera]

The €750 billion Eurobond to pay for the bloc’s recovery from the COVID pandemic “will pave the way for a treasury and common EU taxation”, a cross-party group of EU lawmakers have argued on these pages this week.

It’s a bold statement that, if borne out, would mark the biggest step in European integration since the creation of the single currency.

For the moment, it is still some distance away. This ‘Eurobond’ has been agreed by national leaders and is a one-off with minimal oversight for the European Parliament.

It is hard to say where the €750 billion will come from. The ‘frugals’ have not changed their minds about common forms of EU taxation, nor are they likely to any time soon.

In any case, treaty change would be needed to genuinely make common EU taxation a reality. The prospects of new EU taxes beyond a modest carbon levy being in force by 2030 are extremely slim. Fortunately, in this case, they don’t have to be.

A decade ago, plans for Eurobonds, bank deposit guarantees and financial transactions taxes (to name but a few) foundered because national treasuries in wealthy countries saw that they would immediately suffer an economic hit or higher bond spreads.

European integration has tended to be driven when, as is the case this time, the horse is in front of the cart.

In this case, the bond has been agreed and the €750 billion will hit the European Commission’s balance sheet over the next couple of years.

It will, in turn, have to be repaid at some point in the distant future. That means that a solution will have to be found which, again, opens up a plethora of options, one of which is the common treasury advocated by integrationists.

It is not the only idea on the table. Earlier this month, a group of economists argued that the European Central Bank could simply write off a large chunk of its balance sheet.

That is effectively what the Bank of England has done to cover some of the costs of the near £300 billion in COVID-related spending, racked up by the UK government last year. ECB chief Christine Lagarde has rejected the idea out of hand but that always happens when such a radical plan is floated for the first time.

That is the optimistic view.

There is also the risk that a major political storm has merely been stored up for the future.

Just over a decade ago, the eurozone crisis was caused, in large part, because political leaders from Germany to Greece – and those in-between – were not straight with their electorates about what they had signed up for.

There is little sign right now that national electorates would support a raft of new EU taxes in addition to existing national budget contributions. If governments are not forced to be honest about how the bill will be paid, the risk is that in twenty or thirty years’ time, they will feign ignorance and hide their wallets.


A message from FACEBOOK: Facebook partnerships to fight against COVID-19. Working together is more important than ever in the fight against COVID-19. In Spain, the World Bank is using Facebook’s Disease Prevention Maps to forecast needs for COVID-19 testing and hospital beds. Learn more about how we’re collaborating to keep communities safe and informed at about.fb.com/europe .


The Roundup

Before you continue clicking through our articles, have a read of our weekly newsletters on Global Europe and Digital.

Russia has dismissed as unsubstantiated, deplorable, or ill-informed a recent statement by European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen, who wondered why Moscow is offering millions of vaccines around the world while it has not vaccinated its own population yet.

An increasing number of Greek artists and athletes have come forward in recent weeks to report cases of sexual harassment in the world of sports, TV and theatre, exposing a well-hidden secret in Greece.

Cyprus hit out at Turkey for acts it said were behind the creation of a new migration route that had “disproportionally burdened” it with the EU’s highest percentage of asylum-seekers.

Thirty days after Joe Biden entered the White House, the US is officially back in the Paris Agreement.

Ireland is edging towards a vote to ratify CETA, between Canada and the European Union. CETA has been implemented provisionally since September 2017, but needs final approval by all EU parliaments, before full implementation.

The European Commission has issued draft adequacy approval on transfers of personal data between the EU and the UK, noting however that it will ‘monitor’ progress and rescind the decision should the UK diverge from EU data protection rules to a ‘problematic’ degree.

The EU’s new long-term budget and Recovery and Resilience Fund, worth €1.8 trillion, offer a once-in-a-generation opportunity for the EU and Bulgaria, Elisa Ferreira, Commissioner for Cohesion and Reforms told a mostly Bulgarian audience.

Look out for…

  • EU27 video meet Navalny aides on Sunday, ahead of the EU Foreign Affairs Council on Monday

Views are the author’s

[Edited by Zoran Radosavljevic]

Subscribe to our newsletters

Subscribe
Contribute